Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Ego Death

Our discussion of "body time" vs. "clock time" echos a deeper discussion of the rational (conscious mind) vs. the irrational (subconscious) mind. Freud's theory of the personality is an interesting framework to use. Stealing some definitions from Wikipedia [1]:


  • the id is the set of uncoordinated instinctual trends
  • the super-ego plays the critical and moralizing role
  • the ego is the organized, realistic part that mediates between the desires of the id and the super-ego


Source
We also see this framework in the classic idea of having an angel on one shoulder and a devil on the other -- the superego and id, respectively, with a person in the middle as the ego to mediate between the two. The ego is what we often associate with our conscious identity: it is the upper-most "layer" in the brain, if we use a computing analogy like the 7-layer model, which holds that the lowest layer of complexity is the physical layer (the transistors and circuit boards in a computer, neurons in our brains), and the highest layer is applications in computers, and consciousness in humans. 

Source


So if the ego is simply the organized, rational part of our consciousness, why does the word "ego" have such a negative connotation? Where did terms such as "egotistical," "egomaniac," or "ego trip" come from? They all stem from becoming too attached to a concept of self. We know that our bodies are transitory - cells constantly divide, or die, and our brains are governed by chemicals that are heavily influenced by our environments. Why, then, do we expect to have a consistent, rational identity, if we are tied so closely to a chaotic physical embodiment?

The concept of "ego death" is used to refer to a realization that the ego is illusory, that there is no continuous "self" from one moment to the next. Wikipedia again says it pretty well [2]:
  • Ego death is characterized as the perceived loss of boundaries between self and environment, a sense of the loss of control, personal agents, and cognitive-associations. This re-organization, reidentification, and reinterpretation of boundaries between self and environment experienced through sensations of wholeness or by refutation of the "I".
Ego death experiences are associated with many religious experiences, including meditation and prayer, as well as lucid dreaming, sensory deprivation, and psychedelic drugs. It is often reported that a great sense of peace and happiness comes from realizing that you are "part of something bigger than yourself." Of course, we're all raised to believe (and instinctively, we believe) that our identities are real, and our names refer to a permanent "self" or "soul," and that our identity ends at the barrier of our skin. Ego death experiences are difficult to achieve and even more difficult to maintain. It's all well and good to realize that I am a speck of cosmic dust, totally interconnected with the universe, but I still need to feed myself, get a job, and therefore go to school and care about grades and other trappings of the ego.

Questions I have about this include: has anyone experienced ego death? Is the ego necessary for human progress (ie: is there any reason, if I let go of my identity, to care about grades or personal achievement?)? How is the ego related to our concept of physics and how we interpret the world (ie: the ego perceives time, so time must be a physical reality)? Do you think that humans will ever evolve past ego, or is it a necessary part of being human? Is all of this just something that a bunch of crazy hippies came up with? I welcome any thoughts you have.


Monday, September 30, 2013

Anomaly and Error: A New Kind of Problem Solving

Currently, computers represent a technology of undeniable sophistication. We use them to solve a great number of sophisticated problems, including modelling of the worldwide climate and designing chemical reactions that have never occurred. If we open our computers or cell phones, we see a collection of components whose complex arrangement indicates that such a rigid complexity is the only way to accomplish the task of computation.

Certainly, the creation of computers that follow rules (and follow them well) has been a successful endeavor. The concept of an imprecise computer seems to be an anathema: even our rigid computers seem to run on Murphy’s Law and frustration. Nonetheless, they seem to get the job done. We can solve a great many problems, but, in order to do so, we must continue to create computers that follow rules faster and faster.

In place of creation and intelligence, we have speed. At what point does that paradigm break down? To facilitate speed, our computers must be made smaller. At some point, though, the world with which we are familiar begins to break down. Following Moore’s Law, in the not-too-near future, the imprecise nature of the quantum world will clash with the rigid nature of our computers.

Some seem to think that quantum computers represent the solution to this problem. To my limited understanding, a quantum computer is fundamentally unable to solve any new problems. We can solve certain problems faster, but we will still be limited by the rigid structure that has become so fundamentally necessary to our conception of computation.

If we examine the computer as a device to solve problems, we can examine a great many things under the definition. Further, we can ask, do other systems exhibit the same rigid structure of our friendly neighborhood problem solver? To my knowledge, in virtually all cases, the answer is no.

Presented with the problem of surviving on this unpredictable planet, the solution is evolution. In short, life could not persist without error. Error allows us to adapt, to change with a changing environment. Presented with the problem of consciousness, we understand that our brains are imprecise, our thoughts governed by the unpredictable course of electrical and chemical signals. All around, we see evidence of systems that thrive because of imperfection and error. Rigid systems do not persist for long.

What, then, will come of our technological obsession with rigidity? Certainly, that structure will persist for some time. However, I think the threads of the next technological revolution are currently visible. In addition to quantum computers, current research is being undertaken in the field of Amorphic computing. Amorphic computing relies on many imperfect simple components. Much like cellular automaton such as Conway’s Game of Life, meaningful phenomena emerges from a system that is let to run, without the influence of external guides.

At the moment, our computers are remarkably well-suited to solve our problems, but they do so in ways we wouldn't. Instead of creating increasingly complex computers, with technologies that exist solely to facilitate a perfect system of order and rules, we can embrace anomaly. In the not-too-far future, when our problem solving infrastructure begins to clash with the physical world, perhaps we must embrace the natural world—imperfection and all—to continue adapting.

                        

Mirroring Happiness

Most of our discussion of time has been based on combating our individual relative feeling of time with the mechanic "clock" time that we use to organize our societal lives.  To me this is very similar to the nature of Revolutions that must originate and proliferate in the hearts and minds of individuals that then go forth and distribute the ideas to the target society.  I can't help but believe that there isn't a clear divide though between the internal, individual decisions and the societal implications.  I have a few examples that led me to this question.

I don't know how many people have heard about "Mirror Neurons" but I find them fascinating.  The following American Psychological Association articles describes them.
http://www.apa.org/monitor/oct05/mirror.aspx
Long story short: mirror neurons are neurons that fire when you witness something happen in the same way that they would fire if you were the person you witnessed.  They do not distinguish between you as an observer or you as an actor in the situation.  These studies and definitions of course have huge ramifications in terms of basic human learning and development as well as our ability to experience extreme empathy.

So where am I going with this?  Mirror neurons show that every moment of our life, our brains are bombarded with information and, unless we are in complete solitude, our mind can easily confuse if the signals are original to our experiences or original to those around us.  Time cannot be an exception.  Undoubtedly, sitting in a class of engaged students makes the class feel faster than one in which every student is asleep.  Of course, the largest source of our internal perception of things is our actual internal perception of things, but mirror neurons point out that there is a gray area of environmental interference.

The second topic that I'd like to tie in is the studies of happiness and gratitude.  Below is the Georgia Psychological Association study and corresponding YouTube video (I suggest the YouTube video for a less-scientific but more engaging approach).
http://www.gapsychology.org/displaycommon.cfm?an=1&subarticlenbr=309
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHv6vTKD6lg
Again Long story short: expressing gratitude goes a long way towards increasing your happiness.  In a world where the mind exists in its own closed system this would appear contradictory.  It is not the existence of gratitude that increases happiness, it is the expression of it.  Expression, by definition, is making known one's thoughts and feelings, most often to others.

The idea of Revolutions originating internally and proliferating externally is overly simplistic and excludes the important ramification on the revolutionist's mind from their environment.  Just as Lightman suggested that Einstein's theory was influenced by his uncontrollable dreams, American Founders were influential upon each other, and an unremarkable woman was influenced by a moment to do the remarkable and stay in her seat at the front of the bus.

Thursday, September 26, 2013

The Reality of Time

After discussing Einstein's dreams, contemplating his realities and attempting to create my own, I began to think about the idea of time from a human perspective. Yes, it is easy to define time as the constant movement of a hand around the white face of a clock, or the reliable sun up sun down system, we somewhat derived this clock idea from, but are those things really time or just a way of normalizing everyone's relative clock to make our society functional?
By that I mean that, what if true time was the speed at which our brains analyzed the reality we live in? In which case it would be possible that time is not a constant. As I am sure you have experienced, the activities we do affect the rate at which we "perceive" time. Consistently, we gripe and groan about the monday to friday work week and its length, but when it comes to vacation, a week isn't even close to enough time for some well needed R&R. Why is this?
My proposition is this. Our bodies do in fact experience different rates of time. While the absolute normalized clock demonstrates on the outside what the "time" is, our bodies may experience this time at a different rate which is almost never constant. This idea would create some explanation as to those who are happier, live longer. Possibly, being happy releases a chemical that induces your body to experience life at a slower rate, where as unhappy people experience the opposite.
While we see time as the amount left in a class, or until the end of the week, or vacation, what time really counts is the time our body has left on this planet. So why not pay attention to this "clock" and do things that enable us to change the rate at which it operates. Do things that make us happier so that we might live longer.

Wednesday, September 25, 2013

Out of my comfort zone: Simile poetry challenge

So I mentioned to Toni that I'm not too big a fan of similes because they feel sort of cheesy to me. I like metaphors because they can be anything; they're not constrained by word choice. They don't need to say this is this directly, they let you infer what this is like. Even so, Toni gave me a "Poetry Challenge" sheet that asked you to fill out several similes and to pick a few and write a poem. So here it is:

Perspective

If I should wake before I die,
I should like to know I made at least a small difference.

It feels like stones being lobbed at my heart
Repeatedly
Just to make sure that I feel small and worthless.

I feel powerless sometimes
Like there’s nothing I can do to be better
Everything wrong is my fault

I try and I try and I try
To fix the things I cannot change
To change the opinions that won’t be changed by me.
I can only change ME.

She held her life in her own hands as if it were a new and special gift.
I can choose to be positive
Respectful
To Listen
To try to understand what’s needed from me.

I can choose to do my best
To accept others’ opinions as differing from my own.
I do not have to let them define me.

Nothing was the same, now that it was in her charge.  

Quantum Information Poetry

I stumbled across a blog from the Caltech Institute for Quantum Information and Matter, somewhat similar to our blog. More specifically, a colleague linked me to this post, "The complementarity (not incompatibility of reason and rhyme."


It features a brief discussion of the the author's introduction to quantum information poetry, but the highlight is the author's poem about her research.

I could try to define all the terms she uses, but I think in that would cause the poem to lose some of its charm. Much of the piece's appeal comes from the way the author juxtaposes heavy technical references with a light, airy tone. Reading it (at least first) without fully understanding what she's talking about is a neat way of seeing how poetry can make sense even a little out of context.

I wish her the best of luck in getting Physical Review Letters to publish the sequel.

Friday, September 20, 2013



Time is a slippery subject. Like Socrates’ attempts to futilely define virtue, time is an ever present concept that elusively escapes mankind’s grasp. Time is a richly varied concept within human history, but even that is difficult to understand. Behaviorally modern humans have been around for approximately 50,000 years. That is quite a long time considering the entire span of recorded history is only around 5,000 years. Yet humans have been around for much longer. In fact, anatomically modern humans have been mucking about for 200,000 years. People who look just like you and I have been on this planet for 200,000 years and we’ve only managed to record less than 3 percent of it.

Homo sapiens have had quite a number of ideas about what time is and how it works; many of these ideas are outlined in our reading Einstien’s Dreams. What I find particularly interesting, however, is modern physics’ take on the subject. One concept is that of imaginary time. Keep in mind that the word ‘imaginary’ is not meant to imply a departure from reality, but rather a different kind of time. This is a time that runs orthogonal to what we know as ‘real’ time and it comes from Quantum theory. This imaginary time along with the three directions of space make up Euclidean space-time. Steven Hawking and James Hartle have proposed that imaginary time and space together are finite in extent, but without boundary. A way to conceptualize this is to think of the surface of a balloon. Imaginary time along with space is the surface of the balloon. You can go all the way around the balloon and never leave the surface. This is interesting in that it seems a parallel to a cyclical way of viewing time. Real time marches on in a more or less linear fashion while imaginary time seems to circle around. This view of time is quite intriguing on a philosophical level as to how our universe came to be as well as on a scientific level since it helps to avoid singularities in the Big Bang theory.

I have to wonder, though, what the real impact of this is. Yes, it is fascinating to daydream about, but in the end what does this mean in the grand scheme of things. To me, generally, it seems that science attempts to figure out the truth of reality by looking outside ourselves while religion attempt the same by looking within. Both are on the same quest for “the answer”, only taking different paths to this end.

What if humans were to go extinct tomorrow? What would the consequences be? The health of the planet would surely improve. The impact on the universe would most certainly be negligible. Perhaps the only loss would be in the Universe no longer learning about itself.