Monday, September 16, 2013

Quantum Mechanics, Time, and Yoga


 


I am safe and sound, good things come to me, they bring me peace

Bones, muscles, movement; anxiety, elation, depression; everything, I give onto the hands of peace
I am free, I am free

On the surface quantum mechanics and yoga are diverse concepts with no real relationship to one another, but they are all centered on the idea of unity. In the film "What the Bleep Do We Know?!" quantum mechanics is explored for its implications that reality is much more intricate than it even appears to be with an infinite number of layers of complexity and detail that must interact to create a coherent reality. We live in a complicated world of cells, atoms, and the macroscopic but we have a unity of these concepts to produce a sense of wholeness and unity within ourselves and with the wider world. One of the biggest implication of this intricacy is the idea that we are all inescapably connected to each other and our entire reality. How we choose to see the world, how we choose to see our past and future affects our perception and perhaps even time itself. The speakers in the movie discussed scientific theories and experiments that are showing how we are all contributors to the reality we experience and that of others. This idea was especially advocated through the experiments on the effects emotions and thoughts have on the structure of water. The film advocated that labeling water with either positive or negative words directly affected the crystalline structure of the water, positive words induced a seemingly harmonious and artful structure where as negativity disrupted that harmony and caused much more erratic and essentially stressed structure. This principle was applied to the fact that our bodies are 70% water and that these same principles of the effects of thought could take place within us. By quantum mechanics our thoughts and ideas have more significance than we ever thought before and we are accountable for their effects, we are important to the whole of reality for our significance as conscious beings with the power to change the world.

These same principles have been essential to yoga throughout history. I have been a practicing yoga for seven years now and in that time I have found that it's emotional and mental benefits even outweigh the physical. Through the setting of intentions, use of affirmations, meditations, and other emotional support in posture yoga has always embraced the idea that each of us is important to the world be it with our thoughts, actions, or attitudes and utilizes this in every aspect of the practice. Intention and affirmations are used to center the mind and being on the positive even in the most difficult postures. An example of posture affirmations are listed above. Their purpose is to change how the mind views pain or stress by focusing it on a positive idea. Even if the affirmation is nothing like the actual feelings a yogi has in the poses these affirmations distract the mind and allow one to sink into the practice and find peace and enjoyment despite any perceived level of pain or stress. The basic idea is that by thinking positively one can physically feel that peace, that thoughts affect our physical state. Intentions expand on this idea to a statement about yourself for you to keep with you even after the practice, primarily about your relation to the wider world. This is a valuable activity because it extends that awareness of the importance of our thoughts in our interactions with others and is a reminder of our effect on others. Yoga is also very involved in removing the emotional roadblocks in our own lives by physically excising them through motion. Everything from our atoms to cells to muscles to thoughts to interactions are connected and we can affect our thoughts through movement just like we can affect our interactions through thought.

Both quantum mechanics and yoga share the same fundamental ideas and principles even though their creation was separated by thousands of years, yoga is thought to have begun as early as the stone age and substantiated by 3000 B.C while quantum mechanics is a 20th century scientific theory that is still developing. This is where my primary question comes in. In our class discussions Lincoln briefly asked about the connection between ancient Egyptian belief and current science and what exactly that connection implies. Yoga is an ancient and well established practice and seems to have already been aware of the very breakthroughs in the implications of quantum mechanics that we are still discovering. How do we rectify this seeming resurgence of ancient ideas? Do we brush the connections off as backwards mysticism that could never compare to our science? Is it the result of the circular time dreamed by Einstein? Is it information encoded in our souls? Our DNA? Do we see the desire for knowledge about the wholeness of creation and our unique importance to be an innate longing?

As the traditional salutation of yoga, as a way to acknowledge both yourself, those around you, and the rest of the universe:
Namaste

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Culture and Truth: Validity versus Correctness and Cultural Relativism



                I would like to apologize in advance: this post is going to jump around a little bit, but hopefully it will come together in the end for the determined reader. In class on Wednesday Lincoln brought up the idea of validity as opposed to correctness. I can’t recall exactly how he put it, but he used the contrast of the classic art hanging in the Louvre and more ‘mundane’ art hanging in another museum. This brought to mind a very similar critique of the state of ethnography by Cora Du Bois, a professor of anthropology. Du Bois, as cited by Renato Rosaldo in Culture and Truth, described the “distance she felt from the ‘complexity and disarray of what [she had] once found a justifiable and challenging discipline… It has been like moving from a distinguished art museum into a garage sale.’” [1] Du Bois’ critique arose as a result of the diversification of the field of anthropology. The classic ways of writing ethnographies are being reevaluated as more individuals from different walks of life take on the role of ethnographer. For Du Bois it seems as though this reworking of anthropology through the inclusion of minority authors is leading to a degradation of the integrity of the field. In the past, names like Geertz, Boas, Malinowski, and Levi-Strauss were treated with veneration and their works treated as the standard upon which all subsequent works were to be judged; now they are as open to critique as is an ethnography written by a chemical engineer with no background in anthropology.

                In class we also briefly discussed the interesting fact that there are surprisingly few individuals like Alan Lightman who have a multidisciplinary background in both the humanities and the hard sciences. We noted that many of the great discoveries of recent times were made by individuals with their feet in two worlds. Additionally, we discussed the effect of perception on the world. Why does some art end up in the Louvre while some art gets set out at a garage sale? I believe that it has to do with perspective. Someone decided that one artist’s work was more valuable than another’s, so one artist becomes more famous while the other is left out. When one artist becomes famous, they are featured in museums and suddenly their techniques and critiques become more valid than those of the garage sale artist. Because people see the museum artist as valid, he becomes correct about everything related to art while the garage sale artist knows nothing, his work is not as valid a contribution to the artistic world, and he is not valued as highly. In reality, there is no universal scale against which to measure the works of the two artists, no grand art judge who can definitively say which is superior. Van Gogh was not famous during his lifetime; people did not view his work as valid, correct, or valued. But now he is a household name. 

                This same process applies to anthropology: graduates from certain schools have more academic prestige, thus their work is granted more validity, and then suddenly their analysis of a culture is the only correct analysis. Contributions made by “native ethnographers” who may or may not have received training in anthropology and who may or may not be biased in their reports are disregarded because they are not as correct as papers filled with anthropological parlance and terminology. In a field that focuses on humanity, culture, and the human condition, isn’t every viewpoint valid, even if not necessarily ‘correct’? 

In his book, Rosaldo argues that anthropology needs to be more open to the contributions of minority groups. He calls for a change in the way that ethnographies are written and for an inclusion of the human element in case studies and reports. He also points out the seeming impossibility of remaining objective in anthropology. Ruth Benedict describes the issue eloquently in Patterns of Culture: “No man ever looks at the world with pristine eyes. He sees it edited by a definite set of customs and institutions and ways of thinking. Even in his philosophical probings he cannot go behind these stereotypes; his very concepts of the true and the false will still have reference to his particular traditional customs.” [2] In this case, isn’t it extremely important to have multidisciplinary individuals involved in anthropology? Is the same true for engineering and the hard-sciences?

The following questions that occurred to me while writing this post. Since I can’t come up with answers, I thought I would share them and see what you all thought:

Cultural relativism is a tool used by anthropologists in an attempt to avoid making ethnocentric judgments upon first contact with a bizarre cultural practice. It is a way of lending validity to other ways of life without necessarily deeming them to be ‘correct’. Does cultural relativism fit into the harmony or the unity paradigm better?

How would Aristotle, using his four causes, explain something like mortuary cannibalism or headhunting?

Sources:
[1] Culture and Truth: The Remaking of Social Analysis, Renato Rosaldo, 1989.
[2] Patterns of Culture, Ruth Benedict, 1934

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Representation, Algorithmic Complexity, and Quantum Mechanics


How is representation related to the three global paradigms of unity, complexity, and harmony? 

A key underlying issue in global paradigms is the standing problem of representation: what is real?  Plato addressed this problem in terms of his theory of forms, in which he postulates that all our experiences are shadows of shadows of the true form.  In Meno, an early Platonic dialog, he is already formulating this concept by moving the real definition of virtue beyond our grasp.  In the Amduat, an Egyptian tomb text, representation is found in terms of numinal quantities, the gods, each one a part of our psyche in manifestations of archetypes, as Kacie grasped immediately and pointed out.  In this sense the gods in the Amduat are useful mental representations, not explanations of natural phenomenon, any more than our beloved stories and films serve that purpose.  What kinds of representations are we using in science?  Humanity spent a long time transitioning from inner, complex representations as we find in the Amduat to unifying representations as begin in Plato and culminate in Grand Unified Field Theories in physics, as we see in the standard model of particles and fields.  Likewise, the attempt to use survival of the fittest and Darwinian evolution to explain so much of biology is another example of an attempt at a unifying theory.

In fact, science has been tremendously successful at providing clarity in the paradigm of unity.  Recently this paradigm has been challenged by the advent of complexity.  Complexity includes features like emergent phenomena, hierarchies of scale, connectivity, and yes, chaos.  Measures of complexity include Kolmogorov or algorithmic complexity, which measure complexity by the length of the representation, in particular the computational resources needed.  So for example even though pi is an infinite bit string, since it can be calculated from just a few lines of computer code, pi is not very complex.  Likewise, many kinds of chaos and fractals are not complex in this sense.  On the other hand the internet, DNA, consciousness, and many other phenomena do not appear to be representable in a simple algorithm, or even by iteration over that algorithm.  Scientists still hope that such complex phenomena will come down to equations, and it is hard to prove otherwise.  But for the moment it appears that complexity is common in the universe, does not appear as any obvious result of fundamental physical law, and cannot be represented by a simple algorithm in most cases.  Thus the paradigm of unity (science through the mid to late twentieth century) is giving rise to a new paradigm of complexity now.  Perhaps this paradigm is not that of the Amduat.  However, we can understand some basic concepts in the Amduat scientifically.

First, unity, a single state, has entropy zero.  For the Egyptians and the Sumerians this state is nothingness, uninteresting.  Only diversity gives rise to life and interest, to the plethora of gods, representing the complexity of the human mind, found for example in the Amduat.  Complexity has continued as a philosophical and religious paradigm in Hinduism and Indian cultures today.  Complexity is re-appearing naturally in the sciences and it may be that we need a new paradigm to understand it, one which relies less on grand unified field theories and more on diversity.

Second, we now know that quantum logic is more efficient at solving certain problems, in particular factoring large numbers (Shor's algorithm).  So although any problem may be represented by binary logic (yes/no or true/false), in fact some are more efficiently represented by quantum logic, or other forms of probabilistic logic, called modal logic in philosophy.  The Amduat prefers to avoid dichotomies like yes/no in favor of multiplicity.  It is a system of thought, albeit in a language and format we cannot relate to very well today, which emphasizes modal logic over binary logic.  There are several manuscripts of Egyptian mathematical proofs (Reisner papyrus, Rhind mathematical papyrus, Akhmim wooden tablets), and one finds many interesting theorems in them, with correct reasoning: however, the approach to those theorems is different from ours. 

Coming back to representation and what is real, quantum mechanics has provided very strong evidence that at some level reality is non-local and probabalistic.  Every time we test quantum mechanics, it does even better.  As Deborah pointed out, even the many worlds interpretation has now become a mainstream possibility, with serious considerations in physics of the universe as one possibility in an infinite multiverse.  A century ago none of us would have imaged a probabilistic non-local representation of reality would be meaningful, let alone accurate and useful enough to build digital computing technology from.  What will we find out in another century?  What might a new investigation of complexity teach us to see?

I leave the discussion of harmony, a paradigm employed and enjoyed in China, comprising ~1/4 of the world's population, for another post.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

"19 April 1905" and the Many Worlds Interpretation, or Einstein, that's the wrong physics revolution!

In the "19 April 1905" vignette in Alan Lightman's novella Einstein's Dreams, a man stands on his balcony and ponders whether to go to a woman. He has three options: to stay away, to go to her and start a relationship, or to go to her but not start a relationship. He does each, but in different worlds.

The man on the balcony can do this, not by trick or treachery, but because everyone in this world can do this. Whenever a decision is made, the world splits into three distinct worlds. Eventually, there are an infinite number of worlds [1].

As I was reading this piece, I was struck by its similarity to the Many Worlds Interpretation of quantum mechanics (MWI). The MWI argues that any time a quantum experiment with more than one outcome with non-zero probability is performed, all the outcomes are achieved in different worlds [2].

While there exists only one universe in MWI, there are an infinite number of worlds within the universe. ("Worlds" are defined to be combinations of all macroscopic objects. Macroscopic objects are things like tables, cats, and people.) These worlds are constructed from quantum states corresponding to macroscopic objects, and objects are constructed from the wave functions of elementary particles combined into atoms combined into molecules combined into cells [2].

In equations, that looks like:
To reference a common example, in MWI, Schrodinger's cat is alive in one world and dead in another [2].

What I find most interesting about the integration of this concept into "19 April 1905" is its link with Einstein. (It is, of course, his dream.) Notoriously, Einstein held that quantum mechanics was not a complete theory and not the future of physics. He took issue with the Copenhagen Interpretation of quantum mechanics (the predominant interpretation and an alternative to MWI), saying "I, in any case, am convinced that He [God] does not play dice" [3].

I find the inclusion of a multi-world conception of time interesting, at least as a physics in-joke, though I am not yet sure what (if anything in particular) its purpose is.


References
[1] Lightman, Alan. Einstein's Dreams. New York: Vintage Books, 1993.
[2] Vaidman, Lev. "Many-Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics." The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Edited by Edward N. Zalta. 2008. http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2008/entries/qm-manyworlds/ (accessed September 11, 2013).
[3] Norton, John D. "Einstein on the Completeness of Quantum Theory." Einstein for Everyone. 2013. http://www.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/teaching/HPS_0410/chapters/quantum_theory_completeness/ (accessed September 11, 2013).



Saturday, September 7, 2013

Why Religion?


The First Hour of the Egyptian Amduat is a perfect example of how ancient peoples often used religion to explain natural phenomena. I have often also heard people say that religion began when people first encountered death since death is mysterious and confusing. In a world where science can answer questions about our universe, what is the role of religion today? If religion’s only purpose were to serve as a default for things we could not explain, why are there so many faithful followers today? If science holds the key, why would anyone at Mines believe in an Omniscient Being? Why does Stephen Hawking remain a professed atheist while some of his contemporaries are devout in some religion or another?

I was able to speak with Aaron about this topic on Wednesday, and we started talking about faith and what it meant. Aaron mentioned how sometimes it seemed that people expressing “faith” just accept things without question or doubt and that these same people too often say, “God works in mysterious ways.” (I hope I paraphrased you correctly, Aaron. If not, I apologize. Please correct me.) I responded by saying faith is an expression of humility when we realize that we cannot know everything and that we must trust that events happen for a reason.

The question remains: For what is Pablo Neruda searching in his poem Unity? Do we seek closeness to “The Old One” as Alan Lightman states in his book Einstein’s Dreams, or is being a member of a religion comparable to joining a club or other organization based on common interests?

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Touchscreen



I think that Marshall Davis Jones does an amazing job of portraying the digital society that we were talking about tonight in class.  When it comes to this paradox of increased communication technology resulting in a deficit of personal human contact, I am still not sure where I stand.  I can definitely agree with Marshall's ideas that by digitizing our methods of interaction, we are not only losing the potential development of true kinship with others, but also risking the physical devolution of our human bodies and the desensitizing of our human spirit.  Nearly anywhere I go on any day, most of the humans I see are hunched over a laptop with horrible posture, or staring at their smartphone while they distractedly try to speak to a friend at lunch; and yet, I am only able to witness this during the odd occurrence when my own eyes are not directed at a small LED screen, so who am I to judge?

On the other hand, as both a scholar and world traveler, I am obviously very aware of how important and beneficial communication technology is (as I'm sure we all are) in spreading ideas, knowledge, and emotions to friends and family all around the world.

So what next?  Marshall ends with the brilliant line, "When our technology is advanced enough to make us human again."   Is that really a possibility?  Will better technology someday allow us to communicate with anyone anywhere while we are standing upright, speaking face-to-face, and sharing emotions like homo sapiens have for centuries?  Some may argue that with anything short of a teleporter, this "true" form of interpersonal communication will never again be obtained by society through the use of technology.  Others may argue that it is not needed and that our digital communication is a much better form of communication that gives everyone an "equal playing ground" so to speak, since they don't necessarily have to worry about shyness or body language.  Perhaps the problem is not in the technology itself, but in the way we use the technology and change our personal interactions in life.

I cannot escape the irony that I watched this YouTube video on a computer and then posted it to an internet blog (though for what it is worth, the video was originally described to me face-to-face by a friend).  Wouldn't it be humorous if the key to solving this problem turned out to be the use of communication technology to spread this idea of emotional human interaction to people all over the world?  What a revolution that would be!

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

Art's Significant Role in Revolution

I was really struck by the quote in Erik Hornung's book Concepts of God in Ancient Egypt about the way people try to describe our world: "The language in which we speak of the world will never be contained entirely in mathematical formulas, nor will it be contained entirely in words" (pg. 258).

Take this photo for example:
Sorry I don't know which book this came from, my boss just tore out the pages for an exercise with my students.

(Forgive the fact that it's a picture of a picture).

Imagine if I tried to describe this with only words. I could use words like desperation, salvation, need, want, fear, hunger, beggars, and youth. I don't know what's going on necessarily, but it looks like someone out of the shot is passing something to these boys that they want more than anything in the world at that moment. They seem to be lower income, with thin faces and protruding ribs.Yes, this seems like an adequate description, and some of the words seem to match up with the image, but something is missing.

Imagine if I tried describing this with only mathematical/physical equations.
But somehow I feel like I could go on for a long time using equations to describe small characteristics I noticed, but it seems a little tedious.

There is something to be said about an image; it can convey a dozen messages without a single word. It can emulate an emotion the way a thousand words or equations could not. It's not to say that words and equations do not describe the world well, but there comes a time when they just aren't enough.

I believe this idea is relevant in modern revolution. The words/message of a movement can bring about a collaboration of people or a whole revolution can be started from new equations (relativity for example), but revolution often needs art and emotion to truly capture the whole story. Think of some common images we've seen for revolutions and revolutionary movements; the essence of the event is captured in a picture of a swarm of people or of a leader's determined face. Revolution, especially in the age of photography and video, is not the same without art.