Saturday, November 16, 2013

I have seen revolution.

I have seen the smiles;
I have seen the tears.
I have seen the joy of being reunited;
I have seen the fear of being torn apart.
I have seen the exhilaration of learning something new;
I have seen the vacancy of an empty mind.
I have seen the gardens growing tall;
I have seen the soil ravaged, depleted.
I have seen the love and comfort of a family;
I have seen the horror of brother striking brother.
I have seen the elation of freedoms granted;
I have seen the anguish of privileges revoked.
I have seen the praise of a beloved leader;
I have seen the muffled cries under a ruthless tyrant.
I have seen the beauty of a thriving spirit: growing, maturing;
I have seen the writhing pain of a starving child, neglected spirit.
I have seen the opportunities of physical and mental health;
I have seen the blank stare of the sick, past the edge of hope.
I have seen the confidence of a sure path;
I have seen the turmoil of an uncertain life.
I have seen the leisure granted by technology;
I have seen the looming threat of an unmanned drone.
I have seen the tenderness of a generous soul;
I have seen the cruelty of self-indulgent disregard.
I have seen more than I can understand;
I have seen too little yet to answer all of the questions.

Culture and Human Exceptionalism



We spent a lot of time this past week trying to find the key aspect of humans that makes us unique. We discussed sentience, emotion, survival instincts, faith, and nature vs. nurture. Culture didn’t really come up. I recently found a rather ridiculous article about an anthropologist who was “kidnapped by elves” for seven years.


This is obviously not a very credible source, but it did get me thinking. Anthropology is the study of humans and human culture. What would an anthropologist make of a transhuman being, aliens, androids, or even elves?

It turns out that there is actually a movement within anthropology that is examining “culture” as it pertains to other species. This movement seems to be primarily focused on other species found right now on earth such as dogs and racing pigeons. One of the main drivers of this movement is Donna Harraway (Harraway wrote “A Cyborg Manifesto” which was referenced in our study guide for Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?).

Culture is defined as “learned values, beliefs, and rules of conduct that are shared to some extent by the members of a society, and that govern their behavior with one another.1” Culture differs from instinctual behaviors in that it must be learned, and therefore taught. Are human beings unique in having developed “culture”? Do you think that the androids in Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? had a culture?

1)      Bonvillain, Cultural Anthropology, 3rd Edition, Pg. 4.

Thursday, November 14, 2013

Close, but no cigar...


In the following YouTube video you can see the android replica of Philip K. Dick. I have also attached a link to a recently released book about the project http://www.pkdandroid.org/
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJ930zzYxl8

As you can see, we are a long way off from needing special tests to distinguish between human disguise and our mechanical creations. The speech recognition errors abound and his (its?) movements are jolting; in addition, he must remain stationary. But the realism of the androids' facial features is certainly worth noting.
In his article “The Android and the Human” (1972) Philip K. Dicks writes,  “Perhaps, really, what we are seeing is a gradual merging of the general nature of human activity and function into the activity and function of what we humans have built and surrounded ourselves with….Our electronic constructs are becoming so complex that to comprehend them we must now reverse the analogizing of cybernetics and try to reason from our own mentation and behavior to theirs—although I suppose to assign motive or purpose to them would be to enter the realm of paranoia; what machines do may resemble what we do, but certainly they do not have intent in the sense that we have; they have tropisms, they have purpose in the sense that we build them to accomplish certain ends and to react to certain stimuli.”

After last night’s class I wonder what can we glean from the growing animation of the things that surround us?

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Dear Mrs. President

Dear Mrs. President, We Have a Dream…
Dear Mrs. President, We want a change
Dear Mrs. President, We want a change for the betterment of society
Dear Mrs. President, We are the Children of the world

Dear Mrs. President, We can be whatever we want, engineers, doctors, teachers or mothers
Dear Mrs. President, We want equality in the world

Dear Mrs. President, We like to play with dolls and toy cars
Dear Mrs. President, We wish we could have our childhood

Dear Mrs. President, We are trying to change to world for us
Dear Mrs. President, We want to make the world an ethical place
Dear Mrs. President, We want the world to be a happy place
Dear Mrs. President, Can you help us please?

Dear Mrs. President, We are expected to succeed
Dear Mrs. President, We are set up to fail

Dear Mrs. President, We are not a group we are individuals united
Dear Mrs. President, We have a common goal ready to make a change for our children
Dear Mrs. President, We want people to not be suffering and have food on the table
Dear Mrs. President, How long will it take for the world to be a better place?

Dear Mrs. President, We like to play on playgrounds
Dear Mrs. President, We like to have fun with others
Dear Mrs. President, We are scared how the world is turning out
Dear Mrs. President, We like to smile

Dear Mrs. President, We are scared for our future
Dear Mrs. President, Countries are at war with other countries, brother against brother
Dear Mrs. President, We are living in a happy bubble in our own little world

Dear Mrs. President, We have a dream…
Dear Mrs. President, The world is not a place I want to grow up in


Dear Mr. President, We want a Revolution

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

The Human Tendency Toward Empathy

While thinking about Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, I remembered this video:


If it's this easy for us to personify and empathize with a lamp, I can't imagine how hard it would be to prevent empathy for a humanoid robot!

Monday, November 11, 2013

The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat

I've been reading through a book recently, called The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, which is a collection of short essays about people with rare neurological conditions. For many of these people, their brain deteriorates to the point where they have trouble interpreting reality correctly.

The first story, which the book is named after, is the story of Dr. P. He has a condition where "not only did Dr P. increasingly fail to see faces, but he saw faces when there were no faces to see: genially, Magoo-like, when in the street he might pat the heads of water hydrants and parking meters, taking these to be the heads of children; he would amiably address carved knobs on the furniture and be astounded when they did not reply."

This sounds funny, but the crux of the condition is that Dr. P. is able to sense everything perfectly, but loses the ability to sort visual sensory input properly - he must rely on certain outstanding characteristics, like an unusual nose, to recognize people. As the title suggests, he loses the ability to recognize his wife by sight, though he still remembers her personality and recognizes her voice perfectly. Not only this, but he loses the whole idea of facial recognition, and fails to even try. A more extreme example, mentioned only in passing, was of a patient who became blind after a thrombosis but also forgot what sight was, and had no memories of ever seeing anything.

The second story deals with a man who has almost perfect retrograde amnesia - he cannot remember anything after 1945, even though the story takes place decades later. The author reflects on what this means for the patient, venturing into the moral and spiritual realms. If you can't remember what you were doing five minutes ago, do you have a continuous identity? Do you have a soul? Is our status as "human" dependent on our memory?

These questions resonated with me, and with the questions raised by our recent reading of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? The novel is set in the distant future, but I think it's worth remembering that even now, people exist who are turned into "androids" of sorts just through accidents of brain damage. I think that Philip K. Dick, with his schizophrenia, was acutely aware of this. It's my belief that severe enough neurological conditions, ones which cause a disconnect from reality and a lack of empathy, are able to take away people's status as "human." I'm interested if anyone disagrees; is "humanity," perhaps also defined by the idea of a "soul," a fundamental quality bestowed upon the beginning of a human life?

Also, here's a link to a pdf of the book. I'd recommend it to everyone, especially those interested in the medical field. I had trouble not just copying and pasting the whole preface into a blog post, it's really relevant to a lot of topics that we've been discussing.

Friday, November 8, 2013

The Nature of Duality in Revolutions

I have to live with the fact that I'm human.
I live with the fact that I'm human.
I love the fact that I'm human.

I wrote the above poem as I was thinking about what it means to be human and about the things I like and dislike about myself. The book Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? addresses the role of empathy in being human, but humans have a multitude of qualities that distinctly make us human. For example, we can read and write and have invented many languages upon which we've constructed our socities. Yet there are undesirable qualities in our humanity. We have the capacity to hurt other people. There is a constant battle inside of us; and I believe this is why we are attracted to movies and stories that pit good versus evil, dark versus light, and right versus wrong.

In class we have discussed whether or not the science or the application of the science is revolutionary. I argue that the scientific knowledge of nuclear physics is revolutionary, but the paths taken in the application of nuclear knowledge are also revolutionary. New nuclear discoveries did not necessitate their application either to bombs or to medicine. Each one of these applications was a separate leap in itself. By making nuclear bombs, we give into the human response of fear and choose death and destruction. By applying nuclear technology to medicine, we follow our human inclination to love and take care of people.

I propose that all revolutions take place when a person--and it just takes one person-- chooses one side of a certain aspect of his or her human duality over the other.